Sunday, February 23, 2025

Did I Expect Too Much?

In one of my exam questions, I gave the students the average radius of Earth's orbit around the Sun at 150 million km. I told them that we can assume that the orbit is circular. I even gave them the formula for the circumference of a circle.

The question then asked them to find the speed of the Earth as it moves around the Sun.

After the exam and after the results were published, a number of students told me that I did not give them enough information to solve the problem. They said that they could figure out the circumference of the circle to correspond with the distance that the Earth has traveled, but they don't have any information on the time of travel and thus, can't find the speed.

I argued that they should know this because it is common knowledge.

Did I expect too much? Did I make the wrong assumption that everyone (especially 1st and 2nd year university students) knows that it takes the Earth one year to make one complete orbit around the Sun? Was this something I should have given them?

Zz.

No comments: