Did I Expect Too Much?

In one of my exam questions, I gave the students the average radius of Earth's orbit around the Sun at 150 million km. I told them that we can assume that the orbit is circular. I even gave them the formula for the circumference of a circle.

The question then asked them to find the speed of the Earth as it moves around the Sun.

After the exam and after the results were published, a number of students told me that I did not give them enough information to solve the problem. They said that they could figure out the circumference of the circle to correspond with the distance that the Earth has traveled, but they don't have any information on the time of travel and thus, can't find the speed.

I argued that they should know this because it is common knowledge.

Did I expect too much? Did I make the wrong assumption that everyone (especially 1st and 2nd year university students) knows that it takes the Earth one year to make one complete orbit around the Sun? Was this something I should have given them?

Zz.

100 Years of Quantum Mechanics

I mentioned earlier of an article on the Davisson-Germer's experiment as part of the commemoration of 100 anniversary of Quantum Mechanics (QM). This is an article describing a bit more of the celebration and the importance of QM. Hint: without QM, none of your modern electronics (computers, smartphones, etc.) will work.

Zz.

The Davisson-Germer Experiment

As we continue to celebrate 100 years of Quantum Physics, this is a fun account of the famous Davisson-Germer experiment that was the first to demonstrate the wave-like nature of electrons.

It's interesting that, at the end of the article, it was pointed out that this experiment did not originally was set out to seek the experimental evidence for the wave-like nature of electrons. They were intended to do something else, and then learned about something, and adapted it later. This is not really that unusual. The first thing that popped into my head was the discovery of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) by Wilson and Penzias. They certainly were not looking for the CMB with their microwave antenna. It was a serendipitous discovery. In fact, one can even say that the discovery of superconductivity also came out of an experiment that was not designed to look for it, because no one knew at that time that such a thing could exist.

One could say that this is another one of those "Who Ordered That" scenario.

Zz.

5 Physics Equations Everyone Should Know

Rhett Allain posted this article on Wired on the 5 physics equation that "everyone" should know. They are, in the order that was presented:

1. Newton's 2nd Law of motion
2. The wave equation
3. Maxwell's equations (he cheated a bit because this is a set of 4 equations)
4. Schrodinger's equation (natch!)
5. Einsten's energy-mass equivalence equation
   

You can read the article to see what he has to say about each. I'm going to show this article to my students and see what they think, or maybe ask the how many of these do they think we will encounter in the course.

Zz.